Who will win GOTY 2026? The favourites by critic scores

Who will win GOTY 2026? The favourites by critic scores

We won’t know who wins Game of the Year at The Game Awards 2026 until 10 December. You can already compare how critics rated the six nominees, though. As of 20 November 2026, Metacritic gives the highest Metascore to Grand Theft Auto VI (99), followed by The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (95) and Resident Evil Requiem (89). Below you’ll find all the scores, the nomination counts and why critic scores don’t automatically decide the winner. No predictions or betting tips, just verified data.

THE GAME AWARDS: 2026 Nominee Reveal! (Game of the Year)

How the Game of the Year winner is chosen

Under the official rules of The Game Awards, winners are decided by a blended vote. The jury carries 90% and is made up of more than 100 international media and influencer outlets, while fan voting carries 10% on thegameawards.com. Fans can vote until 9 December 2026 at 9 PM ET (6 PM PT).

Each outlet votes based on the collective opinion of its whole editorial team, not one person. Aggregator scores such as Metacritic are therefore only indirectly related to the outcome: they show how reviewers received the games, but the jury votes separately and nobody knows the results before the show. According to the FAQ, not even publishers are told in advance.

Metascores of the Game of the Year nominees

We took these numbers from the main game pages on Metacritic on 20 November 2026. Metascore is a weighted average of selected critics’ scores on a 0 to 100 scale. It can still move while reviews come in, most of all for GTA VI, which only launched on 19 November.

Resident Evil Requiem: a ruined city under a grey sky
Resident Evil Requiem. Source: Capcom (Steam)
GameMetascoreReviewsReleasePlatforms per Metacritic
Grand Theft Auto VI99158November 2026PS5, Xbox Series X
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time95134November 2026Nintendo Switch 2
Resident Evil Requiem89141February 2026PS5, Xbox Series X, PC, Switch 2
Phantom Blade Zero8860October 2026PS5, PC
007 First Light87102May 2026Xbox Series X, PS5, Switch 2, PC
Control Resonant8390September 2026PC, PS5, Xbox Series X

Ocarina of Time here is the 2026 version for Nintendo Switch 2. The original 1998 game has a separate Metacritic page and isn’t included. For a closer look at the GTA VI reviews, including scores from major outlets, see our GTA 6 reviews roundup.

Total nominations for each contender

Another measure is how the jury rated the games in the other categories. We counted these from the official list of all 30 categories:

GameTotal nominationsOther categories besides GOTY
Grand Theft Auto VI8direction, narrative, art direction, score and music, audio design, performance (Manni L. Perez), action/adventure
Control Resonant6direction, narrative, art direction, audio design, action/adventure
Resident Evil Requiem6direction, narrative, audio design, performance (Angela Sant’Albano), action/adventure
Phantom Blade Zero5direction, art direction, score and music, action
007 First Light4narrative, performance (Patrick Gibson), action/adventure
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time4art direction, score and music, action/adventure

Four of the six are also up for Best Game Direction: GTA VI, Control Resonant, Phantom Blade Zero and Resident Evil Requiem. 007 First Light and Zelda aren’t in that category. The full tables for every category are in our article with all the nominees.

What the numbers tell you and what they don’t

  • Highest Metascore and most nominations: as of 20 November 2026, both belong to Grand Theft Auto VI. It launched on 19 November 2026, a day before the eligibility cutoff, and was nominated on 17 November. The rules allow the jury pre-release access.
  • Ocarina of Time has the second-highest score but four nominations. Under the rules, remakes are eligible if the jury considers the new creative and technical work worthy of a nomination.
  • Control Resonant has the lowest Metascore of the six yet six nominations. Nomination counts and Metascores don’t have to line up.
  • The gap between 99 and 83 is big on Metacritic, but the jury votes independently, so the tables can’t predict the result.
Control Resonant: a figure on a marble ledge among floating debris
Control Resonant. Source: Remedy Entertainment (Steam)

We’ve also covered two of the nominees in the news: the launch of Phantom Blade Zero and the Extended Operations update for 007 First Light. For GTA 6 walkthroughs and tips, head to our GTA 6 guides.

When we’ll know the winner

The show starts on Thursday, 10 December 2026 at 7:30 PM ET (4:30 PM PT), which is 12:30 AM GMT and 1:30 AM CET on Friday. The organisers haven’t published the order of the categories. Streams and start times by time zone are in our how to watch guide.

Tell us on Discord which game you’d give Game of the Year to, and join us to watch the show live. Here’s the invite: GamersTogether Discord.

FAQ

Which nominee has the highest Metascore?

Grand Theft Auto VI with 99 from 158 reviews, as of 20 November 2026. The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time is second with 95.

Does Metacritic decide the winner?

No. Winners are decided 90% by a jury of media and influencer outlets and 10% by fan voting. Metacritic plays no part in it.

How many nominations does GTA VI have?

Eight, more than any other game. Besides Game of the Year it is nominated for direction, narrative, art direction, score and music, audio design, performance and action/adventure.

When is Game of the Year 2026 announced?

At the show on 10 December 2026. The broadcast starts at 7:30 PM ET, or 1:30 AM CET on 11 December.

Information verified on 20 November 2026. Metascores can change as new reviews come in. We’ll add the winner after the show.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Shopping Cart
Scroll to Top